Brains, Brawn, and the Skilled Labor Alternative
By Tom McDonald · · 4 min read

In his blog “Passions, Skills and Opportunities,” Garrett Rice wrote last month about a Reddit post highlighting weak employment opportunities for those with select college degrees. Garrett gave some great advice on reframing those skills to improve one’s marketability while emphasizing the importance of continually adding relevant skills to one’s resume.
Recent numbers corroborate, showing that white-collar hiring is slowing while demand for skilled labor is increasing. Note the term “skilled labor” has replaced “blue collar.” The complexity of what we are asking machinists, electricians, welders, automotive and med techs, heavy equipment operators, and plumbers to build, operate, or repair has become increasingly complex.
Semiconductor manufacturing is booming, as geopolitical tensions have forced the US to move these vital operations here. Along with the urgency to reduce carbon emissions, the combined investments from the CHIPS Act and Infrastructure Bill will lead to nearly 4 million high-tech manufacturing jobs by 2033. These jobs will require knowledge of photolithography, metallurgy, chemistry, physics, robotics, 3D printing, IoT, and more. So, while these roles still require physical labor, technical expertise is required, too.
Yet even in highlighting this shift, some continue to show a bias against skilled labor jobs. Aaron Terrazas, a Glassdoor economist, said, “It’s a buyer’s market for brain and a seller’s market for brawn.”
Quippy, but the quote ignores the fact that these roles now require quite a bit of intellectual firepower.
That narrative around skilled labor has to change. It’s an outdated bias that contributed to the multi-generational flight to college degrees and the erosion of vocational education nationwide. As enrollment declined, underfunded community colleges with outdated curricula closed, as did vocational schools that fell out of favor.
Without significant changes in training and new investments in vocational education, nearly half of those 4 million jobs could go unfilled. In Ohio, Honda is building a new battery plant, and Intel is building two semiconductor plants. However, the shortage of skilled labor has Ohio Lieutenant Governor Jon Husted stating, “We’re creating jobs faster than we can find people to fill them.”
The post-college job challenges Garrett cited are not lost on Gen Zers. Nationwide, undergraduate college enrollment declined 8 percent from 2019 to 2022, the steepest on record. Yet many of us were raised with the idea that the path to prosperity was through a college degree.
What advice do we give our children now?

Prosperity, National Security, and Purpose
Last week, at the 80th anniversary D-Day ceremony, President Joe Biden drew strong parallels between the autocratic regimes defeated in World War II and those that threaten democracy today. The parallels are not hyperbole. In fact, one could argue the threat is more severe today, in that critical technology and resources are either controlled by, or in the crosshairs of those autocracies.
However, World War II was not won in the European and Pacific theaters alone. Spurred by Franklin Roosevelt’s December 1940 “Arsenal of Democracy” broadcast, the 16 million skilled workers behind the world’s most potent manufacturing economy pivoted to producing weapons, vehicles, ammunition, ships, aircraft, and supplies. The Arsenal of Democracy was as important to the victory over autocracy as any battle overseas.
Unfortunately, the US no longer has a strong manufacturing base to pivot to. Where did it go? Over the past 50 years, the percentage of US manufacturing GDP has shrunk from 27% to 12%, with upwards of 30% going to China. Those nearly 2 million new domestic jobs at risk of going unfulfilled will not only impact company profitability, but could also leave vital supply chains exposed to conflict or takeover for an extra year or two.
As a parent of a Gen Zer, I have seen how passionate that generation can be regarding issues such as climate change and war. Skilled labor’s role in national prosperity and security is a message with purpose and one that can resonate.
Expanding the Career Narrative
Many are already sounding the alarm for a 21st-century Arsenal of Democracy. Some have provided detailed outlines of what governments and institutions can do. Yet some of these plans will require bipartisan cooperation, a scarce commodity right now.
The good news is that companies are adapting independently. McKinsey reports that businesses are developing a template to engage, train, and retain Gen Zers. Last week, Walmart announced new training programs to address the shortage of skilled workers.
However, the narrative around skilled labor as a viable, alternative path to a satisfying career must start before entering the workforce.
Parents can get involved with local grade and high schools to ensure that courses are modernized and presented without bias towards these roles. That means not only adding STEM courses or dropping “AI” into course descriptions, but ensuring that foundational knowledge and life skills required for skilled labor are added to curricula. Students should also be made aware of the positive impact these jobs have on lives and communities.
The conversation can start at home, too. Young adults who don’t have an affinity for data science, mathematics, or physics should still look to degrees in history, art, sociology, or media, but with the early understanding that jobs related purely to those skills are harder to come by. Some will do just fine in freelance roles. Contractor site Upwork consistently reports workers on their platform are happier than those with full-time jobs. Alternatively, many have found the flexibility of gig work fits their lifestyle. But might general trades, such as plumbers or electricians, offer some of the same gig worker flexibility but with greater upside? There is plenty of demand for these skills, which can provide compensation levels that rival tech workers.
Parents have always been able to influence their children’s career paths. We must all understand that these new high-tech manufacturing and skilled labor jobs require both brains and brawn. By discussing these options early with our children, we can better ensure that all pathways to their prosperity remain available.