Judged by the Cover Letter
By Jennifer Burnside · · 3 min read

Do you ever feel judged by your cover letter? Like compared to what it says about you, you just don’t add up? Does your cover letter try to act like it’s better than you?
The two main challenges with cover letters are:
- Accurate representation
- Alignment to the specific role
Representing yourself accurately is vital, for honesty’s sake. You should not exaggerate, while at the same time, you must lift yourself up as a qualified and desirable worker. Such a delicate balance! A cover letter serves as your formal introduction, giving a taste of who you are. It takes some time to craft, but shouldn’t take so much time that you miss the application deadline. Try to apply to a job within two days of discovering it, for maximum chances.
There is an art to the balancing act between quality and efficiency. This means you should start writing cover letters now. Write about who you are and what you have accomplished. While this sounds like it’s all about you, it’s really about what aspects of your history and your present skills can be transferred to the role you are aiming for. Think forward. Be optimistic.
If you are applying to multiple companies for various job titles, you will find the need to shift your language per cover letter, based upon the skills you focus on. If you submit the same cover letter for each one, you will not accurately portray the connection between you and what the employers are looking for. It’s vital that you gather your key words and phrases—the common denominators between who you are as a professional and what the role entails.
Where to start when all you have is an empty page? Never fear. We’ve got your back. Our product creates concise AI-generated cover letters for you, based upon the elements of your resume and the job description at hand. Once you have read through the magically swift results, I recommend an expressive re-write to make the letter your own. Treat it as a template your writerly inspiration transcends.
As a writing instructor, I guide my students to post-outline their written works. By decomposing the communication, objective distance is made between writer and writing. Sometimes we become so invested in the things we have written, that it feels nearly painful to shape or trim them. However, revision is a must.
The steps to post-outlining are as follows:
- Read your cover letter out loud
- Underline key words and phrases
- Take note of the function of the paragraph (intro/support/conclusion)
- Summarize the main idea of each paragraph (you can use key words as clues)
After you post-outline, read your letter out loud again. How does it sound? Does it make sense? Was anything particularly hard to annunciate or did any sentence drag on past 2 lines? Did you hear a word pop up repeatedly? Take the time to re-phrase and cut parts as needed. Done!
You might ask if cover letters are even reviewed these days. It really depends on the company. I’d say whether or not you are required to attach a cover letter with your job application, it’s best to write one. This prepares you for persuading employers that you are the most eligible candidate for the role. You will persuade yourself as well.
You might end up using the cover letter as notes for a future elevator pitch, illustrating how you’re the most incredible and noteworthy fit for the job. Think of the writing as a thought exercise—a time for reflection culminating in an organized declaration of your wise strength.
If you get this uneasy feeling that your cover letter is scrutinizing you and maybe even judging you, it’s time to grab a mirror and dig deep. Why do you feel uncomfortable? Are you being clear and authentic? Are the facts around your history true? Is the tone of your writing accurate with the way you normally write when communicating in a professional capacity?
You be the judge of your cover letter. Don’t let it judge you.
Take back control! You get to direct where it goes and how it flows.
After all, your cover letter is the trailer to the blockbuster movie that is you.